Tesla CEO Elon Musk set the Intertubes buzzing but once more on Friday, when Reuters scooped the information that he met with two high-level Biden administration officers in Washington, DC. Electrical car manufacturing and EV charging station buildout have been reportedly on the menu. That raises the query of whether or not or not Tesla will conform to a single customary for charging stations in North America aside from its personal.
Excessive degree assembly or not, Volkswagen is among the many auto makers more likely to follow the CCS EV charging customary, at the very least for now (picture courtesy of Electrify America).
Quick Reply: Nope
As of final fall, Tesla indicated that it does need a single customary, which occurs to be its personal expertise and never the acquainted Mixed Charging System (CCS) utilized by virtually the entire remainder of the trade. The corporate went forward and proposed one thing known as the “North American Charging Normal,” though no such customary exists exterior of Tesla’s publicity machine.
That places the corporate at odds with different US and international automakers that help the Mixed Charging System, first launched in 2011. Although automakers in Japan and China proceed to make use of their very own programs, CCS has been adopted as the usual by each different automaker in Europe and North America besides Tesla.
Excessive-level assembly with White Home officers or not, Tesla seems nowhere near becoming a member of the remainder of the automotive gang on CCS. As an alternative, the corporate is on monitor to make it simpler for different EVs to make use of an adapter to make use of Tesla charging stations within the US and Canada, because it has completed in different international locations.
Why Can’t Tesla Be The Precise EV Charging Normal?
Earlier this month CleanTechnica’s Jennifer Sensiba identified a number of explanation why different EV charging stakeholders are not more likely to change from CCS to Tesla. She famous as effectively that Tesla’s charging tools doesn’t at present qualify for tax incentives beneath the Inflation Discount Act. The IRA specifies “non-proprietary connectors that meet relevant trade security requirements,” Sensiba wrote, which suggests CCS.
To qualify for the incentives, Tesla may undergo the identical years-long approval course of undertaken by the automotive stakeholders that supported CCS and proceed to help it.
Nonetheless, as famous by Sensiba, the worldwide EV charging pace-setting group CharIN (stands for Charging Interface Initiative) has pulled the rug out from beneath that concept. “Why reinvent the wheel?” is an efficient abstract of its stance.
“CCS has gone by way of a few years of rigorous standardization processes, which is a required exercise for any new customary proposal. After a decade of collaborative work, the home and worldwide EV trade has aligned round CCS,” said the North America chapter of CharIN final November.
CharIN name-checked Audi, BMW, Daimler, Ford Motor Firm, Common Motors, Honda, Hyundai/Kia, Lucid, Lotus, Mazda, MAN, Mercedes-Benz, Navistar, New Flyer, Nikola, Nissan, PSA Groupe, Proterra, Renault, Rivian, Scania, Stellantis, Subaru, Suzuki, Tata Motors, Tesla — sure, even Tesla — Toyota, Volvo, and Volkswagen as “automakers which might be utilizing and supporting CCS.”
The group went additional, warning that adopting Tesla’s charging system would set the entire trade again as an alternative of accelerating the transition to EVs.
“… we encourage stakeholders to analyze methods to deal with market acceleration quite than the creation of one more kind issue various, which can result in additional shopper confusion and delay EV adoption,” CharIN said.
CCS Is Not The Solely Impediment
Apart from specifying CCS, the Inflation Discount Act may additionally affect Tesla not directly. Beginning this yr, the federal tax credit score for EV charging stations is simply obtainable in non-urban and low-income communities. These limitations are at odds with the profile of the standard Tesla purchaser, which developments white, rich, and male.
In opposition to this backdrop, it’s doable that Musk mentioned workarounds for each EV charging station requirements and tax credit score limitations on the assembly on Friday. As reported by Reuters (right here’s that hyperlink once more), he met with Biden advisers Mitch Landrieu and John Podesta, a senior adviser to the President answerable for the power transition.
Good luck with that. Because the senior infrastructure coordinator for the Biden administration overseeing the disbursement of Inflation Discount Act funding, Landrieu could be keenly conscious of the disruptive danger of embracing a brand new EV charging customary at this stage of the sport.
As for Podesta, he isn’t just one other “Democratic stalwart,” as described by Reuters. Podesta served beneath Presidents Clinton and Obama. He additionally based the well-known liberal suppose tank Middle for American Progress, which has been keeping track of the goings-on over at Twitter beneath Musk’s possession.
“Whereas pretending to provide energy again to the folks, Elon Musk is definitely turning Twitter into an autocratic system the place neo-Nazi accounts are restored whereas journalists’ accounts are suspended,” CAP said in a press launch final December.
Final week, Enterprise Insider and different information group additionally reported {that a} leaked memo indicated that Musk personally ordered the suspensions.
That is only a wild guess, however it doesn’t appear probably that Biden administration would harm its fame as a bulwark in opposition to fascism simply to engineer particular carveouts within the IRA for Elon Musk.
Model Repute Kicks In For EV Charging Normal
The model fame angle additionally applies on to automakers and different EV stakeholders. In her article, Sensiba factors out that dropping CCS is a nonstarter for different automakers. They’d make themselves appear to be followers, not leaders, in the event that they adopted the Tesla EV charging system after a longstanding dedication to CCS.
The model fame angle is stronger than ever, partly as a result of maturing of the company ESG (setting, social, governance) motion — a motion that Musk has maligned, by the way in which.
At the same time as different automakers try to burnish their ESG profiles, Tesla has been backsliding lately. The aura of mystique surrounding Musk and Tesla has congealed right into a sequence of concrete model fame points, together with allegations of “rampant discrimination” at his Fremont manufacturing facility and his refusal to collaborate on a standard sense public well being response to the COVID-19 outbreak, on high of his conduct as each and account holder and proprietor of Twitter.
On this context, dropping CCS for a Tesla system is a nonstarter. Take Volkswagen, for instance. The automaker confronted an enormous scandal of its personal again in 2015, when an investigation revealed widespread, systematic dishonest on diesel emissions checks. It doesn’t appear probably {that a} German automaker with a worldwide attain would incur additional reputational danger by aligning itself with a high-profile American CEO accused of right-wing sympathies.
As a part of its settlement within the US, Volkswagen launched its Electrify America EV charging station offshoot. Since then, it has change into a mainstay on EV charging station buildout.
In a current replace, Electrify America famous that it “expects to put in or have beneath growth roughly 1,800 complete charging stations with over 10,000 chargers in the USA and Canada by 2026.
As well as, Electrify America has been specializing in the very communities handed over by Tesla’s excessive sticker value. Final December, the corporate introduced one other $3 million funding in help of community-based organizations that promote electrical automobiles in low-income and deprived communities, in California.
“This effort is a part of the corporate’s broader dedication to environmental, social and governance (ESG) practices, and helps the prevailing plan to speculate $200 million in California ZEV infrastructure and education schemes within the state by way of mid-2024,” Electrify America said.
That appears to settle the matter, for now at the very least. When you have any ideas about that, drop us a be aware within the remark thread.
Comply with me on Trainwreck Twitter @TinaMCasey.
Discover me on LinkedIn: @TinaMCasey or Mastodon: @Casey or Publish: @tinamcasey
Photograph: Electrical car charging stations courtesy of Electrify America.
Do not need to miss a cleantech story? Join every day information updates from CleanTechnica on electronic mail. Or observe us on Google Information!
Have a tip for CleanTechnica, need to promote, or need to counsel a visitor for our CleanTech Speak podcast? Contact us right here.